Tony Tonington is a local theater critic that gives a review during the news in "Death by Dinner Party".

He reviews Mrs. Tyler's second grade play H is for Horses, referring to it as 'dreck' and expected more in Langley Falls. When he starts to claim that he'd rather have 'ass-tearing diarrhea,' Greg Corbin yells at him to shut up.

Tony is voiced by Alan Tudyk.

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.