Francine comes up with an elaborate plan to reunite Stan and Roger after a big fight. She fakes Roger's kidnapping in the hopes of showing Roger that Stan still cares about him, but when Stan never shows up to pay the ransom, he simply delayed. Once she realizes that Stan knew all along, she confronts Roger in the hotel he was staying in, telling him that either he'd be nice or he's out of the house. It forces Roger to rethink the way he treats people. For at least a year, he had been nice. However, it turns out that being nice is deadly to Roger's physiology, noted by a flower slowly dying. On his deathbed, he reveals that his species had to be jerks otherwise he'll die.
He creates a big insult of Steve's dancing, restoring himself to health. Though Francine returns to being an enabler, but she will let Stan beat him up when he deserves it. She and Hayley lock him in the attic, leaving Roger to be beaten off screen.
Meanwhile, Hayley and Klaus constantly challenge each other to a true-or-dare game, mainly using dare. Stunts range from Klaus taking a picture of Francine's undergarment and filling his bowl with Jell-O while Hayley had run around naked and say she lost her penis, then dress like Captain Stubing for fourteen months.